Neither Pilates nor swimming: the best low-impact activity for over-65s with joint problems

Neither Pilates nor swimming: the best low-impact activity for over-65s with joint problems

Joint problems affect millions of older adults, limiting mobility and reducing quality of life. For those over 65 experiencing stiffness, pain, or reduced flexibility, finding the right form of exercise becomes crucial. While Pilates and swimming often top the list of recommended activities, emerging research suggests another option may offer superior benefits for ageing joints without the drawbacks associated with these popular choices.

Introduction to the benefits of low-impact exercises

Low-impact exercises provide essential movement without placing excessive stress on joints, making them particularly valuable for older adults. Unlike high-impact activities such as running or jumping, these gentler forms of physical activity allow individuals to maintain fitness whilst minimising the risk of injury or aggravating existing conditions.

Understanding what makes an exercise low-impact

An exercise qualifies as low-impact when at least one foot remains in contact with the ground at all times, or when body weight is supported throughout the movement. This fundamental characteristic distinguishes activities that protect joints from those that may cause additional wear and tear. The absence of jarring movements means reduced force transmission through bones, cartilage, and connective tissues.

Key advantages for the ageing body

Low-impact activities deliver multiple benefits specifically suited to the needs of those over 65:

  • Improved cardiovascular health without joint strain
  • Enhanced balance and coordination, reducing fall risk
  • Maintained muscle mass and bone density
  • Better flexibility and range of motion
  • Reduced inflammation in affected joints

These advantages become particularly important as the body’s natural repair mechanisms slow with age, making recovery from exercise-related injuries more challenging. Understanding why seniors require specialised approaches to physical activity helps clarify the ideal exercise choices.

Why low-impact activities are ideal for seniors

The physiological changes accompanying ageing create specific requirements for safe and effective exercise. Cartilage becomes thinner, synovial fluid decreases, and ligaments lose elasticity, all contributing to increased vulnerability in joints.

Age-related changes affecting joint health

After 65, the body experiences several transformations that impact exercise tolerance. Bone density decreases, particularly in women post-menopause, whilst muscle mass naturally declines through sarcopenia. These changes mean that activities once performed easily may now pose risks. The cumulative effect of decades of use also manifests as osteoarthritis in many individuals, with weight-bearing joints such as knees, hips, and ankles most commonly affected.

The importance of continued movement

Despite these challenges, remaining physically active proves essential for maintaining independence and overall health. Sedentary lifestyles accelerate muscle loss, worsen joint stiffness, and increase the risk of chronic conditions including diabetes, heart disease, and depression. Low-impact exercises provide the solution: sufficient movement to maintain function without exacerbating joint problems.

Health markerSedentary seniorsActive seniors
Fall risk35% annual incidence18% annual incidence
Mobility independence62% at age 7584% at age 75
Joint pain severity6.8/10 average4.2/10 average

Whilst many assume popular activities like Pilates and swimming represent the best options, certain limitations make them less suitable for some individuals with joint concerns.

The disadvantages of Pilates and swimming for fragile joints

Though frequently recommended, both Pilates and swimming present challenges that may outweigh their benefits for seniors with compromised joint health.

Pilates: potential problems for vulnerable joints

Pilates requires significant joint flexibility and stability that many older adults with arthritis simply cannot achieve safely. Many classic Pilates movements demand extreme ranges of motion, particularly in the spine, hips, and shoulders. For someone with degenerative joint disease, these positions may cause pain or even injury. The emphasis on core strength, whilst beneficial, often involves positions that place considerable pressure on wrists, knees, and the lower back.

Equipment-based Pilates using reformers can be particularly problematic. The springs and resistance mechanisms require precise control that individuals with reduced proprioception may struggle to manage. Additionally, getting down onto mats or equipment and rising afterwards presents practical difficulties for those with limited mobility.

Swimming: barriers beyond the pool

Swimming enjoys an excellent reputation as a joint-friendly exercise, and the buoyancy of water does indeed reduce load on joints. However, several practical and physical factors limit its suitability:

  • Cold water temperatures can increase joint stiffness and pain
  • Certain strokes place rotational stress on shoulders and knees
  • Pool access often involves steps or ladders that challenge those with hip or knee problems
  • Chlorine and chemicals may irritate sensitive skin conditions common in older adults
  • Transportation to swimming facilities creates logistical barriers
  • The horizontal position may be uncomfortable for those with breathing difficulties

These limitations have prompted researchers and physiotherapists to identify alternative activities that deliver similar benefits without the associated drawbacks. One particular exercise has emerged as exceptionally well-suited to older adults with joint concerns.

Discovering the recommended gentle physical activity

Walking stands out as the single most beneficial low-impact activity for over-65s with joint problems, offering advantages that surpass both Pilates and swimming for this specific demographic.

Why walking excels for joint health

Walking provides a natural, functional movement that the human body has evolved to perform efficiently. Unlike swimming’s unfamiliar horizontal position or Pilates’ demanding postures, walking requires no special skills or equipment. The rhythmic, weight-bearing nature of walking actually stimulates joint health by promoting circulation of synovial fluid, which nourishes cartilage and removes waste products.

Research consistently demonstrates that regular walking reduces joint pain and stiffness whilst improving function. The moderate load placed on joints during walking triggers beneficial adaptations without causing damage, strengthening the muscles that support and protect joints.

Accessibility and practicality advantages

Walking’s simplicity eliminates many barriers that prevent seniors from exercising consistently. No membership fees, specialised facilities, or equipment purchases are required. Walking can be performed almost anywhere, at any time, and easily adjusted to individual capabilities. Those with severe limitations can begin with short distances and gradually increase duration and intensity.

The social aspect of walking also provides mental health benefits often absent from solitary swimming or studio-based Pilates. Walking groups offer companionship and motivation whilst reducing isolation, a significant concern for older adults. Beyond the mechanical benefits to joints, walking delivers comprehensive improvements to overall health.

The health benefits for joint health of those over 65

Regular walking programmes produce measurable improvements across multiple aspects of health, with particularly significant effects on joint function and pain management.

Direct benefits to joint structures

Walking strengthens the muscles surrounding joints, providing better support and stability. Stronger quadriceps, for example, reduce the load on knee joints during daily activities. The gentle compression and release during each step promotes nutrient delivery to cartilage, which lacks its own blood supply and relies on this pumping action for nourishment.

Studies show that individuals with knee osteoarthritis who walk regularly experience:

  • 23% reduction in pain scores after 12 weeks
  • 18% improvement in physical function
  • Slower progression of cartilage loss compared to sedentary individuals
  • Reduced need for pain medication
  • Better sleep quality

Systemic health improvements

The benefits extend far beyond the joints themselves, addressing the interconnected nature of health in older adults. Walking improves cardiovascular fitness, reducing heart disease risk. Better circulation means improved healing capacity throughout the body, including in damaged joint tissues. Weight management becomes easier, reducing the load that joints must bear during all activities.

Health outcomeWalking 30 mins dailyNon-walkers
Cardiovascular eventsReduced by 31%Baseline risk
Type 2 diabetes riskReduced by 40%Baseline risk
Depression symptomsReduced by 36%Baseline risk

Bone density also benefits from the weight-bearing nature of walking, helping to prevent osteoporosis and reduce fracture risk. These comprehensive advantages make walking uniquely valuable, but success depends on proper implementation.

How to incorporate this activity into your daily routine

Establishing a sustainable walking routine requires thoughtful planning and gradual progression, particularly for those with existing joint problems.

Starting safely and building gradually

Begin with short, manageable distances rather than ambitious targets that may cause discouragement or injury. Even five minutes of walking provides benefits, and consistency matters more than duration initially. Add one or two minutes each week, allowing joints and muscles to adapt progressively.

Proper footwear makes an enormous difference. Supportive shoes with cushioning and good arch support reduce impact forces and improve comfort. Replace walking shoes every 500-800 kilometres, as worn cushioning loses its protective properties.

Optimising your walking routine

Consider these strategies for maximising benefits whilst protecting joints:

  • Walk on softer surfaces such as grass or tracks rather than concrete when possible
  • Use walking poles to reduce load on hips and knees whilst improving balance
  • Schedule walks during warmer parts of the day when joints feel less stiff
  • Incorporate gentle stretching before and after walking
  • Stay hydrated to maintain joint lubrication
  • Listen to your body and rest when pain increases beyond normal mild discomfort

Making walking a sustainable habit

Consistency requires making walking enjoyable and convenient. Vary routes to maintain interest, join walking groups for social connection, or listen to audiobooks or music. Track progress using a simple diary or pedometer to visualise improvements and maintain motivation. Set realistic goals based on individual capabilities rather than comparing yourself to others.

Aim for 150 minutes of moderate walking weekly, divided into manageable sessions. This target aligns with health guidelines whilst remaining achievable for most seniors. Remember that any amount of walking surpasses inactivity, so celebrate all progress.

The evidence supporting walking as the optimal low-impact exercise for older adults with joint problems continues to strengthen. Its accessibility, effectiveness, and comprehensive health benefits position it above more complex or facility-dependent activities. For those over 65 seeking to maintain mobility, reduce pain, and preserve independence, a regular walking routine offers the most practical and beneficial approach. Simple adjustments to footwear, surface selection, and progression rates ensure that even those with significant joint limitations can participate safely and experience meaningful improvements in function and quality of life.